The Hijacking of Liberalism in Higher Education

I have many friends who consider themselves ‘liberal’ or ‘progressive’ — and I think that classic liberalism has some good things to offer as we continue to develop a vision for our nation.  However I am disturbed to see classic liberalism disappearing and being hijacked by an extreme form of leftism — and there is nothing liberal or progressive about this new trend.  If you call yourself a liberal, then I hope you are as disturbed as I am about the way your movement has been taken over by a very different ideology.

The United States was originally envisioned as a Image result for the land of the freeplace where people would have the freedom to express their ideas in respectful ways with each other.  Freedom of religion, speech, assembly, the press, bearing arms, were all written into the Bill of Rights in order to reassure citizens that their basic rights would be protected.  Yet now we see a movement in the academic world and in the popular culture to silence all dissent on various controversial topics including sexuality, family structure, global warming, politics, economics, race relations, religion, and morality.  Those who disagree with leftist ideology are routinely vilified, assaulted, and silenced by various institutions, mobs, media chains, civic organizations, and corporations.

Related imageIn the first few months of 2017 we have witnessed angry mobs shutting down dozens of public forums and speeches scheduled at various college campuses.  The administrations and law enforcement agencies have generally caved to the pressure of the angry mobs.  In a country nicknamed “the land of the free,” we have witnessed free speech being silenced by bullies, thugs, and spoiled students who are apparently too fragile to be exposed to alternative expressions of thought.

One of my first experiences of the closing of the American mind in the modern university setting came when I was a graduate student at Princeton Theological Seminary.  It was during a meeting of the Image result for hate speechAssociated Student Council at the seminary when the council voted to not allow for a campus organization named Presbyterian Pro-Life Fellowship.   The student council decided that this group was not permitted to organize on campus and would not be recognized since it was a politically biased group.  The odd thing about this is that the student council of the seminary had two years earlier voted to give full recognition to Presbyterians for Lesbian and Gay Concerns (PLGC).  The council saw no problem with officially approving this group as a campus organization.  They did not notice anything inconsistent about their decision even though it was pointed out to the council that the PLGC group was clearly a group dedicated to a particular bias and a particular moral/political/legal point of view (i.e. the legitimization of homosexual marriage).  The pro-life group was silenced and marginalized, the pro-gay group was welcomed and affirmed.

That was 30 years ago.   In the intervening 30 year period, the opposition to free speech and diversity of thought on university campuses has become overwhelming.  Hostility toward people who don’t embrace leftist ideology has become commonplace.

American universities which were designed to be places of exploring diversity of thought are now institutions of zealous indoctrination without a single opposing voice being welcomed at the table.   Finding a single conservative thinker in a department of Psychology, Literature, History, Political Science, or Religion,  is like finding a penguin in the Mojave Desert — not many exist, and any that you might find are endangered.

In a recent conversation I had with a person who serves as an academic dean at a large public university how many conservative republicans or Evangelical Christians are on the faculty of his university in the departments of literature, history, psychology, or political science, he said that he could not think of a single example.  He admitted it was lopsided but said the problem is that they do not receive applicants for these positions who are conservative in their viewpoints.  I suspect  the Department of Diversity at his university is not working very hard to remedy that situation.

The modern university has a very skewed Image result for celebrate diversity approach to diversity.  Diversity for these academic leaders is an environment dominated by administrators, instructors, organizations, and  students with different ethnicities, ages, nationalities,  and “multiple genders” who all think, speak, and vote in  exactly the same way — embracing the same worldview.   They all embrace secularism, moral relativism, feminism,  and all the other ‘isms’ that align with leftist ideology.     It’s dishonest and naïve to claim that a modern university ‘celebrates diversity’ — instead they insist on sameness in all of their areas of influence.  The party line on campus is that you must think like a leftist or you will be marginalized, vilified, and silenced.

Image result for university free speech riotsI am not sure that this quote from Noam Chomsky can be substantiated — but if a staunch leftist like Chomsky affirms free speech for his opponents, where are the liberals or progressives who will step forward to turn the tide in a different direction.

I found it refreshing to discover at least one classic liberal who woke up to the realization that liberalism has been hijacked.  His name is  Dave Rubin.    He used to gladly embrace the label “progressive” but now he’s not a progressive.  He has left the left.  He’s an openly gay man who is married.  Why did he leave the progressive movement? You can watch this 4 minute video (link below) to understand what he (and I) are so concerned about regarding the future of liberalism and the progressive movement in our country.  I hope and pray that on topics of religion, politics, science, economics, and all other pursuits,  American universities  can come back to a place of truly honoring diversity, free speech, and free thinking.

Why I Left the Left – David Rubin

Watch the video and let me know what you think.

6 thoughts on “The Hijacking of Liberalism in Higher Education”

  1. Thank you for taking a position on liberalism. Politics is entwined with who a person is, his/her fundamental values. Most people keep with their family or union beliefs and believe what they are told because they are not interested in politics or think Christians shouldn’t be involved. At the moment we are losing our democracy. I pray the other 50% of the population will make it a point to see what is happening. For me, I will be shown as a fool or a bigot to pass the information of Hollywood, the press and TV outlets. They have gotten so bold because Christianity and republicans have not tried to stop what has been happening all this time. I applaud the brave conservative commentators on radio and cable TV for speaking up. They are being ridiculed with hate and damnation. They risk their income and reputations standing up for what is right.

    1. Thanks for reading and replying Gloria. I think we used to have the labels of ‘conservative’ and ‘liberal’ but today a new category is emerging that I would not label as ‘liberal’ since it has changed into something entirely different than what I believe liberalism used to stand for. The new category seems to me to be an extreme form of ‘leftism’ that is shutting down an honest exchange of ideas between liberals and conservatives.

  2. What a well thought out post! I wonder if those college professors who don’t agree with the majority are too intimidated to speak up. I confess that I often sit silently in the lunch room when my coworkers poke fun of our government leaders or conservative views. (This happens a lot in a public school). Mostly, I feel that saying something would only alienate me rather than influence them! I keep waiting for the right moment. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.

    1. Good question Eva. I agree that in many cases we sense that speaking up with people who are deeply set in their ways would only alienate them. We need to know when to speak and when to be quiet, and we should look for windows of opportunity if we sense that people are willing to listen. My biggest concern is with the presidents of the universities who should be standing up for free speech. They are generally afraid that they will lose their jobs or that the students will riot and destroy the campus. So the bullies are calling the shots.

  3. It is too bad that in the editing of this excellent discussion, the photo of the shirt that has the saying “Hate Speech Will Not Be Tolerated” was superimposed upon the text, making the text difficult to discern.

    1. Jerry —
      Thank you for the feedback. I am working with WordPress and sometimes the software does not work perfectly. When I view the post the pictures are separate from the text — but perhaps in other browsers the photos and text get superimposed on one another. If other readers have the same problem, please let me know — and I welcome any ideas for a solution.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *